I considered not posting this because it'll probably spark heated reaction from both "sides" of the "debate". I hope my liberal (pun intended) use of quotes adequately conveys my cynicism. Anyway, I decided to post it because even though I'm too tired and unmotivated to engage in "debate" right now in my life, I'm clearly motiviated enough to share my feelings on the issue. That, in itself, is worthy of posting.
Besides, censoring myself because people don't agree or because it might ruffle feathers would be the most un-Sam thing I've ever done. Can't have that, can we?
Besides, censoring myself because people don't agree or because it might ruffle feathers would be the most un-Sam thing I've ever done. Can't have that, can we?
"Today's decision affirms that the Constitution does not stand in the way of the people's representatives enacting laws reflecting the compassion and humanity of America." - President Bush
Dunno whether to laugh or cry at the total ridiculousness of that statement. Dunno whether to find statistics about how often partial birth abortions are actually performed (not often) or how often, of those performed, they're performed to save the woman's life (pretty often). Of course, two weeks ago I watched a fetus clutch at House's hand and freaked out about people seeing that and thinking it could actually happen.
But, hey. Babies danced in Ally McBeal and the dead talk to what's-her-name from Kids Incorporated (no Fergie jokes, please). So clearly my world view is messed up. Yeah yeah, life isn't like TV. But millions and millions and lots of people watch TV, and I don't trust them to get the difference.
I digress.
I'm always more annoyed by people (conservatives and liberals both) who love love love the Courts when the Courts do what they want, but scream about judicial activism when they don't, than I am about a particular ruling. I think the justice system is more important than politics. Remember when they used to be two different things? Me neither.
I don't really care that a bunch of non-doctors wrote the decision. Duh. They're also non-criminals (sort of) and non-business owners (generally) and non-corporations and most of them don't even know how to use a computer. They're old and out of date. Justice isn't just blind, you know, she's also senile and incontinent and waiting on her Social Security check.
Oh, Ruth. I hope you never retire. She thinks the decision "tolerates, indeed applauds, federal intervention to ban nationwide a procedure found necessary and proper in certain cases by the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists."
I'm pro-choice, man, and I'm also not short sighted. This decision was Bad. I think partial birth abortions are scary, but I think a government that makes choices for its citizens is scarier. People can talk about the fetus being life all they want to, but I'll just wave my arms at all the government perpetuated violence that takes place on a day to day basis.
I realize that a lot of the way this debate is framed isn't about freedom vs. non-freedom, but rather what constitutes a life. We ain't never gonna agree on that one, and in the mean time there's nothing that says freedom more than a person's right to choose. Even if you don't agree.
Well, that and your right to disagree. But it's a tie.
Dunno whether to laugh or cry at the total ridiculousness of that statement. Dunno whether to find statistics about how often partial birth abortions are actually performed (not often) or how often, of those performed, they're performed to save the woman's life (pretty often). Of course, two weeks ago I watched a fetus clutch at House's hand and freaked out about people seeing that and thinking it could actually happen.
But, hey. Babies danced in Ally McBeal and the dead talk to what's-her-name from Kids Incorporated (no Fergie jokes, please). So clearly my world view is messed up. Yeah yeah, life isn't like TV. But millions and millions and lots of people watch TV, and I don't trust them to get the difference.
I digress.
I'm always more annoyed by people (conservatives and liberals both) who love love love the Courts when the Courts do what they want, but scream about judicial activism when they don't, than I am about a particular ruling. I think the justice system is more important than politics. Remember when they used to be two different things? Me neither.
I don't really care that a bunch of non-doctors wrote the decision. Duh. They're also non-criminals (sort of) and non-business owners (generally) and non-corporations and most of them don't even know how to use a computer. They're old and out of date. Justice isn't just blind, you know, she's also senile and incontinent and waiting on her Social Security check.
Oh, Ruth. I hope you never retire. She thinks the decision "tolerates, indeed applauds, federal intervention to ban nationwide a procedure found necessary and proper in certain cases by the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists."
I'm pro-choice, man, and I'm also not short sighted. This decision was Bad. I think partial birth abortions are scary, but I think a government that makes choices for its citizens is scarier. People can talk about the fetus being life all they want to, but I'll just wave my arms at all the government perpetuated violence that takes place on a day to day basis.
I realize that a lot of the way this debate is framed isn't about freedom vs. non-freedom, but rather what constitutes a life. We ain't never gonna agree on that one, and in the mean time there's nothing that says freedom more than a person's right to choose. Even if you don't agree.
Well, that and your right to disagree. But it's a tie.
3 | Comment?